A seemingly innocuous social media interaction has ignited a fiery debate surrounding Zoya Akhtar’s “The Archies,” specifically the performances of newcomers Ibrahim Ali Khan and Khushi Kapoor. Pinkie Roshan, Hrithik Roshan’s mother, has found herself at the center of this controversy after publicly agreeing with a netizen’s review that labeled the film “mindless.”
The incident unfolded on Instagram, where a user posted a scathing review of “The Archies,” focusing on the perceived lack of depth in the narrative and the performances of the younger cast, particularly Ibrahim Ali Khan and Khushi Kapoor, who debuted in the film. The user’s critique went as far as to describe the film as “mindless” and “lacking substance.”
What followed was unexpected: Pinkie Roshan, known for her candid social media presence, responded to the post with a comment stating, “Though I loved the look of the film and the 60s era, I agree.” This simple acknowledgment has since snowballed into a widespread discussion about nepotism, constructive criticism, and the pressure faced by star kids entering the film industry.
“The Archies,” a much-anticipated adaptation of the beloved Archie comics, marked the acting debut of several star kids, including Agastya Nanda (Amitabh Bachchan’s grandson), Suhana Khan (Shah Rukh Khan’s daughter), Ibrahim Ali Khan (Saif Ali Khan’s son), and Khushi Kapoor (Boney Kapoor and Sridevi’s daughter). The film, set in 1960s India, aimed to capture the nostalgia and charm of the original comics while introducing a fresh, youthful perspective.
While the film received mixed reviews overall, the performances of the newcomers, especially Ibrahim and Khushi, came under intense scrutiny. Critics and audiences alike expressed a range of opinions, with some praising their screen presence and others finding their performances lacking in depth and emotional range.
Pinkie Roshan’s endorsement of the “mindless” review has added fuel to the fire, with many questioning her decision to publicly criticize the work of young actors. Some argue that her comment, regardless of her personal opinion, could be perceived as discouraging and insensitive, especially considering the challenges faced by newcomers in the industry.
Others, however, have defended Pinkie Roshan’s right to express her honest opinion. They argue that constructive criticism is essential for growth and that even star kids should be held accountable for their work. This perspective highlights the importance of separating personal connections from professional assessments.
The controversy has also reignited the debate surrounding nepotism in Bollywood. While “The Archies” was lauded for its diverse casting and nostalgic setting, the presence of numerous star kids inevitably sparked discussions about privilege and access. Some argue that these young actors have an unfair advantage over aspiring talents from non-film backgrounds.
In the wake of Pinkie Roshan’s comment, social media platforms have been flooded with reactions. Some have expressed disappointment at her perceived lack of support for the younger generation, while others have commended her honesty. Many have also weighed in on the performances of Ibrahim Ali Khan and Khushi Kapoor, with opinions ranging from harsh criticism to cautious optimism.
It’s important to note that “The Archies” is just the beginning of their acting careers. Like any debut, it serves as a learning experience, and the feedback received, both positive and negative, can contribute to their growth as actors.
The incident has also prompted a broader conversation about the role of public figures in shaping perceptions. While celebrities and their families have the right to express their opinions, they also wield significant influence, and their words can have a profound impact on the careers and confidence of others.
Ultimately, Pinkie Roshan’s comment has served as a catalyst for a much-needed discussion about the complexities of the film industry, the challenges faced by newcomers, and the importance of constructive criticism. It highlights the delicate balance between expressing personal opinions and maintaining sensitivity towards others. As Ibrahim Ali Khan and Khushi Kapoor navigate their nascent careers, they will undoubtedly learn from this experience and strive to refine their craft.
The response to “The Archies” and the subsequent controversy surrounding Pinkie Roshan’s comment underscores the power of social media in shaping public discourse. It serves as a reminder that even seemingly innocuous interactions can spark widespread debates and influence perceptions. As the film industry continues to evolve, it’s crucial to foster a culture of constructive criticism and support, ensuring that all aspiring talents have the opportunity to thrive.
