Ashwni Dhir’s “Hisaab Barabar,” starring R. Madhavan and Neil Nitin Mukesh, arrived with a promising premise: a satirical thriller tackling the timely issue of financial fraud. However, the film has garnered mixed reactions, with some critics and viewers finding it a calculated misstep, while others see it as a missed opportunity. This article delves into the various aspects of “Hisaab Barabar,” exploring its strengths and weaknesses to provide a comprehensive review.
A Promising Premise Derailed?
The film’s premise revolves around Radhe Mohan (R. Madhavan), a righteous government employee and a mathematics whiz, who inadvertently uncovers a major financial scam orchestrated by a powerful and unscrupulous banker, Mickey Mehta (Neil Nitin Mukesh). The conflict between these two characters, representing the common man’s struggle against systemic corruption, held immense potential.
However, many critics argue that the film fails to fully capitalize on this potential. The narrative is criticized for being simplistic and lacking depth, with the satirical elements often falling flat. The film’s attempt to blend satire with thriller elements is also seen as uneven, resulting in a tonally inconsistent experience.
Madhavan’s Earnest Performance and Mukesh’s Underutilized Villainy
R. Madhavan delivers an earnest performance as the principled Radhe Mohan. His portrayal of a simple, honest man fighting against all odds is convincing and relatable. However, even his sincere efforts are unable to fully elevate the film’s shortcomings.
Neil Nitin Mukesh, as the antagonist Mickey Mehta, is largely underutilized. While he portrays the character with the required arrogance and menace, the script doesn’t provide him with enough depth or complexity. As a result, his villainy feels one-dimensional and fails to leave a lasting impact.
Technical Aspects and Supporting Cast
Technically, the film is competent, with decent cinematography and editing. However, the background score and music are unremarkable. The supporting cast, including Kirti Kulhari and Rashami Desai, deliver adequate performances but are given limited screen time and character development.
A Missed Opportunity for Social Commentary
“Hisaab Barabar” had the opportunity to provide sharp social commentary on the issue of financial fraud and its impact on ordinary people. However, the film shies away from delving deep into these issues, opting for a more superficial treatment. This lack of depth is a major drawback, as it prevents the film from resonating with the audience on a deeper level.
Critical Reception and Audience Response
The film has received mostly negative to mixed reviews from critics. Many have criticized the film’s simplistic narrative, uneven tone, and lack of depth. The performances of Madhavan and Mukesh have been appreciated, but they are not enough to salvage the film.
The audience response has also been lukewarm. While some viewers have found the film to be a decent one-time watch, many have expressed disappointment with its execution and lack of substance.
Conclusion: A Disappointing Sum
“Hisaab Barabar” had the potential to be a compelling satirical thriller with a strong social message. However, due to its simplistic narrative, uneven tone, and lack of depth, it falls short of expectations. While R. Madhavan delivers an earnest performance, and Neil Nitin Mukesh shows promise as the antagonist, they are unable to compensate for the film’s shortcomings.
In conclusion, “Hisaab Barabar” is a missed opportunity. It is a film that had the potential to be much more but ultimately fails to deliver on its promise. Whether it’s a calculated misstep or simply a case of good intentions gone awry, the film leaves a sense of disappointment.
“Hisaab Barabar” Fails to Impress: A Review
“Hisaab Barabar,” the latest satirical thriller starring R. Madhavan and Neil Nitin Mukesh, has failed to impress critics and audiences alike. The film, which revolves around a government employee’s fight against a corrupt banker, has been criticized for its simplistic narrative, uneven tone, and lack of depth.
While R. Madhavan delivers an earnest performance as the protagonist, and Neil Nitin Mukesh shows promise as the antagonist, they are unable to salvage the film’s shortcomings. The film’s attempt to blend satire with thriller elements is seen as uneven, resulting in a tonally inconsistent experience.
Critics have also pointed out the film’s failure to fully capitalize on its potential for social commentary. The film shies away from delving deep into the issue of financial fraud, opting for a more superficial treatment.
Overall, “Hisaab Barabar” is a missed opportunity. It is a film that had the potential to be much more but ultimately fails to deliver on its promise
